tight to wear when it is really cold....the rest are just for looks. I think this one below is a nice length.

I also like the length of the one that I wear a lot that is store bought. I should measure it to see what size it is.
I have made several that are too thin. Two of them are made of Noro. I have plans to knit a third and wear all three of them together so they will look a less skinny in a group. I am thinking longer than the short one and shorter than the long one....but in similar colors....I am almost sure that I already have appropriate yarn on hand.

And in February I am adding a Cowl that Stitch Fix sent to me. I would never have bought it in a store....but I absolutely LOVE the look of this cowl on me. I may have to copy this!